Comics New X-Men Ultimate Collection, Volume 1 Review
 

New X-Men Ultimate Collection, Volume 1 Review

New X-Men Ultimate Collection, Volume 1 Review

Details

Purchase:
In North America:
In the UK:
Publisher
Main characters:

First of three volumes collecting Grant Morrison's acclaimed run on the X-Men (renamed New X-Men), the storyline starts with a bang as 16 million mutants are murdered. With new costumes, plenty of black humour and some far-out science-fiction storylines, this really is a brand new take on the X-Men.

Editor review

Final score: 
 
5.0
Palmer Reviewed by Palmer    April 23, 2011
#1 Reviewer   -   View all my reviews

No more hiding in the shadows

Grant Morrison wanted a new type of X-Men book and he was given free rein to do exactly that. The X-Men give up their superhero costumes and instead become educators, campaigners and fighters for mutantkind, complete with cool leather outfits.

For the first time, the world at large learns that Xavier's "school for gifted youngsters" is in fact a school for mutants, leaving the X-Men more isolated than ever before as angry crowds gather oustide the college gates. But mutants are also becoming "cool", and the X-Men are confronted with a human cult which hopes to become mutants themselves.

The villain of the piece is nothing less than the twin sister Xavier never knew he had. She's at least as powerful as him and, as written by Morrison, she exudes such raw malevolence that you can understand why Xavier and his students fear her.

Verdict

The Good:
Morrison's writing in this volume is just superb. The action never lets up but everything happens for a reason and the tale is full of twists and turns.

Emma Frost, a new addition to the X-Men in this book, is so much fun as the amoral teacher with a sordid past. Yes, she used to be a villain but she cheerfully puts this down to the drink and drugs she abused in her youth.

Morrison also introduces a range of brand new characters in the form of students at Xavier's school and gives them each interesting personalities.

One of the best X-Men books ever written, if not the best.
The Bad:
Rather than human beings with remarkable powers, mutants are portrayed in this book as freaks, many of whom barely look human at all. Nothing wrong with that perhaps, but if the X-Men was once a tale of man's inhumanity to man - a potential metaphor for racism or homophobia - it here becomes a tale of man's inhumanity to what is effectively an alien species.
Conclusion:
Essential reading for X-Men fans and a great place to start for newcomers to the X-Men universe.
 

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.

To write a review please register or log in.
 
Frogfear - reviews of movies, comics, television, games and books. Contact This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .RSS

Frogfear - movie, television, books and comic reviews. Read our reviews or log in and write your own.

Welcome to Frogfear

Sign in with Facebook

More reviews

The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen Century: 1969
Editor rating
 
3.0
User rating
 
0.0 (0)
Avengers Disassembled Review
Editor rating
 
3.0
User rating
 
0.0 (0)
Astonishing X-Men Volume 4 - Unstoppable Review
Editor rating
 
5.0
User rating
 
0.0 (0)

What's new