Comics New X-Men Ultimate Collection, Volume 2 Review
 

New X-Men Ultimate Collection, Volume 2 Review

New X-Men Ultimate Collection, Volume 2 Review

Details

Purchase:
In North America:
In the UK:
Publisher
Main characters:

The second collection from Grant Morrison's groundbreaking run on the X-Men, collecting New X-Men 127-141.

Editor review

Final score: 
 
5.0
Palmer Reviewed by Palmer    April 29, 2011
Last updated: April 29, 2011
#1 Reviewer   -   View all my reviews

Magneto was right?

Grant Morrison is widely regarded as one of the best writers the X-Men have had, and this is the second of three volumes collecting his stories.

Always brimming with ideas and humour, the tales in this collection move at a brisk pace.

There are a range of topics covered, from new revelations about Wolverine's past to the slow and painful break-up of Scott Summers and Jean Grey's marriage.

The most interesting section of the book cocenrs a youthful revolt by pupils at Professor Xavier's school for gifted pupils. Rather than embrace the Professor's dream of peaceful coexistence with mankind, the pupils instead opt for the teachings of Magneto, the dead "terrorist" who believed mutants should dominate homo sapiens. Professor X has taught his pupils to dream, but what happens when they have a dream he doesn't like?

Verdict

The Good:
Grant Morrison's X-Men stories have been widely praised, and rightly so. The idea of Magneto becoming a hero to young mutants after his death - complete with "Magneto was right" t-shirts - is a stroke of genius.
The Bad:
The second half of the book focuses on the rebellion by Xavier's students but the first half, which introduces a new mutant character called Fantomex, is less interesting.
Conclusion:
It may not be perfect but it's still one of the best X-Men trade paperbacks ever published.
 

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this listing.

To write a review please register or log in.
 
Frogfear - reviews of movies, comics, television, games and books. Contact This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .RSS

Frogfear - movie, television, books and comic reviews. Read our reviews or log in and write your own.

Welcome to Frogfear

Sign in with Facebook

More reviews

The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen Century: 1969
Editor rating
 
3.0
User rating
 
0.0 (0)
Avengers Disassembled Review
Editor rating
 
3.0
User rating
 
0.0 (0)
Astonishing X-Men Volume 4 - Unstoppable Review
Editor rating
 
5.0
User rating
 
0.0 (0)

What's new